Skip to main content

God and Evil

As my friend, philosopher R. S. Lee, put it perhaps the strongest argument against God is the problem of evil (G. K. Chesterton once quipped that the strongest argument against Christianity was Christians). Many atheists, of the loudmouthed stripe these days, seem to think this is some new evidence that they alone (the "brights" as Richard Dawkins wishes to label his ilk) have marshalled this damning bit of quandry against the forehead of Goliath-like religion with some smooth stone of David. Acutally guys, this reasoning is pretty old. . . ancient, in fact. Many of the ancient Greek dramatists and poets dealt with this topic. And yet, Christians are still here (religion is still here for that matter).
In David Bentley Hart's 2005 book The Doors of the Sea he tackles the problem of evil (theodicy as the ancients knew it) in the context of the 2004 tsunami that killed 1/4 of a million people. This short book is an excellent meditation on the question whether an all-good God is powerless to stop some evil or perhaps whether that all-powerful being isn't quite as good as his PR makes him out to be.
He uses much of Ivan Karamazov's arguments from The Brothers Karamazov to show how powerful these anti-God ideas are. They are legitimate questions. The world is fucked-up (excuse my Anglo-Saxon) in spite of the beauty that can be found. It doesn't do anyone any good when Christians (or other religionists) provide glib answers "It is the will of God/Allah/Shiva etc." So God wants pointless suffering? That's what that answer seems to provide. Bentley replies: "God's gracious will for his creatures--his willing of all things to his own infinite goodness--is the creative power that makes all things to be and the consumate happiness to which all things are called; but this does not (indeed, must not) mean that everything that happends is merely a direct expression of God's desire for his creatures or an essential stage within the divine plan for history."
This short book (I read it in one day) doesn't provide all the answers to the mystery of iniquity and suffering but Bentley does point us in the right direction when he writes in his conclusion:
Until that final glory, however, the world remains divided between two kingdoms,
where light and darkness, life and death grow up together and await the
harvest. In such a world, our portion is charity, and our sustenance is
faith, and so it will be until the end of our days. As for comfort, when
we seek it, I can imagine none greater than the happy knowledge that when I see
the death of a child, I do not see the face of God but the face of his
enemy. Such faith might never seem credible to someone like Ivan
Karamazov, or still the disquiet of his conscience, or give him peace in the
place of rebellion, but neither is it a faith that his arguments can
defeat: for it is a faith that set us free from optimism long ago and
taught us hope instead.
I was never an optimist; I am learning to hope.


Popular posts from this blog

Worth Quoting

"Therefore whoever is not illuminated by such great splendors in created things is blind. Anyone who is not awakened by such great outcries is deaf. Anyone who is not led from such great effects to give praise to God is mute. Anyone who does not turn to the First Principle as a result of such signs is a fool.Therefore open your eyes, alert your spiritual ears, unlock your lips and apply your heart, so that in all the creatures you may see, hear, praise, love and adore, magnify and honor God, lest the entire world rise up against you." -- St. Bonaventure, Itinerarium mentis in Deum

Dirty Hands Can Save You from Hell

"Eternal life will be a shared experience of awe, in which each creature, resplendently transfigured, will take its rightful place." --Pope Francis, Laudato Si
     Wonder and awe abound in the natural world for those with eyes to see and ears to hear.

     Perhaps we are caught short by a vibrant purple emanating from the petals of a wild lupine. We might stare wide-eyed at the lazy circles of a turkey vulture soaring on thermal air currents. Even the most agoraphobic city-dweller can find something beautiful about a landscape even if it's simply the warm and varied red, yellow, and orange of a sunset glowing on a building.

     "The earth is the Lord's and the fullness thereof" asserts the Psalmist. If that verse is true, why don't we live like it? Why are we flabbergasted trying to come up with the names of the many plants and animals we pass by everyday?

     All people respond to beauty in some way or another--even those who have willingly or unwi…

The 11th Hour

If you haven't celebrated Christmas by now, you're not likely to start. Conversely, you don't have to quite let it go yet.

Fight the ahistoricity! It's a feast of twelve days and depending on how you count, this is eleven or Epiphany Eve.

In the Christian East, tonight is the vigil of Theophany.

Theophany/Epiphany are two different sides of the same coin.

The West honors the Magi--who represent all of us goyim--and the miracle at the wedding at Cana (water for wine, anyone?)

The East honors Jesus' baptism, and in more minor ways his circumcision and the Magi, too.

It's all about a manifestation, a revealing, a shining forth. The Trinity is revealed (at the baptism), salvation is revealed to all the world (the Magi), the start of Jesus' public ministry (Cana).

Just as the Incarnation honors all bodies, as the Son suddenly was born with one, so Theophany honors all the Earth's waters.

Paralleling the Jewish Festival of Lights, this perfectly winds down th…